Before you sign anything, pay attention. A job offer is a document that reflects how a company operates — its negotiation culture, its respect for the person it’s hiring, and sometimes its legal exposure. Most candidates read it once, feel relieved to have an offer, and sign before they’ve processed what they agreed to.
Here is what to actually look for — and what to push back on — before you put your name on it.
1. Non-Compete Clauses That Are Broader Than the Role
Non-competes restrict your ability to work for competitors after leaving. In some states they’re unenforceable (California, North Dakota, Minnesota), but in others they’re binding. A red flag is a non-compete that covers an industry broadly rather than a specific function — e.g., “cannot work in the technology sector” rather than “cannot work for these five named competitors.”
Ask for the clause to be narrowed in scope, shortened in duration (six months is common; two years is aggressive), and limited geographically to where you’re actually working.
2. Vague or Missing Bonus Language
If your offer includes a performance bonus, discretionary bonus, or commission structure, the key word to look for is “discretionary.” A discretionary bonus is one the company can decline to pay for any reason. If your offer says “eligible for a bonus up to X%,” that is not a commitment — it’s a ceiling with no floor.
Ask for: the specific criteria for earning the bonus, the historical payout rate, and whether there is a minimum payout threshold. Get it in writing.
3. Clawback Provisions on Signing Bonuses
A signing bonus with a clawback clause means you must repay some or all of it if you leave before a specified period — typically 12 to 24 months. This is normal and reasonable at a baseline. The red flags are:
- Clawback periods longer than 24 months
- Clawback triggered even if the company terminates you without cause
- Prorated repayment that doesn’t reduce proportionally with time served
4. Mandatory Arbitration Clauses
An arbitration clause requires you to resolve disputes with your employer through private arbitration rather than court. This limits your legal recourse, keeps proceedings confidential (protecting the company, not you), and statistically favors employers in outcomes. It’s common — but worth knowing you’re agreeing to it and understanding what it means if you ever need to use it.
5. IP Assignment That Covers Personal Projects
Most offers include an intellectual property assignment clause that transfers ownership of work you create in your role to the company. The red flag is language that extends to work done outside work hours on personal equipment if it’s “related to the company’s business or interests.” Depending on your side projects, this could affect you significantly.
Ask for the clause to be limited to work created during working hours using company resources.
6. At-Will Employment Language That Contradicts Other Promises
Most U.S. employment is at-will, meaning either party can end the relationship at any time for any legal reason. This is standard. The red flag is when the at-will clause is combined with verbal promises about job security, minimum tenure, or guaranteed performance reviews — none of which are enforceable if they’re not in the written offer.
If you were told something material during the interview — a title change after six months, a remote work arrangement, a specific project ownership — it needs to be in the offer letter. If it’s not, it doesn’t legally exist.
7. Start Date Pressure That Doesn’t Allow for Proper Transition
A company that pushes you to start in less than two weeks without a clear business reason is either poorly organized or using urgency as a negotiating pressure tactic. You are entitled to give appropriate notice to your current employer. A start date you agree to under pressure is a start date you own — the company will not remember that they pushed you if you burn a bridge leaving your previous role too fast.
8. Benefits That Are “Effective After 90 Days”
Most employers delay benefits eligibility — health insurance, retirement matching — by 30 to 90 days. Ninety days is the outer edge of normal. Longer than 90 days is a red flag. Also check: whether COBRA coverage from your previous employer will carry you through the gap, and whether you’ll have any uncovered period.
9. Title That Doesn’t Match the Responsibilities
If the job description describes VP-level scope and the title they’re offering is Senior Manager, that gap matters. Title affects external perception, future salary negotiations, and how you’re positioned for your next role. It’s negotiable — and the time to negotiate it is before you sign, not after.
10. No Clear Reporting Structure
If the offer doesn’t specify who you report to, confirm it in writing before signing. Reporting structure determines your access to leadership, your visibility, and the quality of support you’ll receive. “You’ll report to the team” is not a reporting structure — it’s an ambiguity that tends to resolve against you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should you look for before signing a job offer?
Review non-compete clauses, bonus language, signing bonus clawback terms, mandatory arbitration clauses, IP assignment scope, at-will employment language, start date terms, benefits eligibility timing, title alignment with responsibilities, and reporting structure before signing.
Can you negotiate terms in a job offer letter?
Yes. Offer letters are negotiable. You can negotiate salary, title, start date, non-compete scope, signing bonus clawback terms, and IP assignment language. The window to negotiate is before you sign — not after.
What is a red flag in a job offer?
Red flags include overly broad non-competes, discretionary-only bonus language with no performance criteria, signing bonus clawbacks triggered by termination without cause, IP clauses covering personal projects, verbal promises not included in the written offer, and start date pressure that forces you to leave your current role poorly.
Are non-compete clauses enforceable?
It depends on the state. California, North Dakota, and Minnesota have largely banned non-competes. In most other states, they are enforceable if reasonable in scope, duration, and geography. Overly broad non-competes can often be challenged, but it requires legal action after the fact.
What happens if verbal promises during hiring aren’t in your offer letter?
They are generally unenforceable. If something material was promised during the interview process — a specific role, a remote arrangement, a title change timeline — it must be in the written offer to be binding. Request it in writing before signing.
Know what you’re signing before you sign it.
Subscribe to WMN Magazine — career intelligence for women who negotiate from a position of knowledge.
